My compilation of sauces tried so far with my notes on each
-Tapatio adds a very slight hotness, very mild
-Frank's, same as Tapatio but with a little bit more of a kick
-Gringo Bandito, small bit of hot with a slight smokyness that overtakes the hot taste
-Trappey's Bull, recommended by LouCypher, has a very similar taste to Tabasco but overall better tasting.
-Hot Ones, the sauce from the YouTube channel Goshin posted (
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPD...pmmeQcbe2kpPaA)
This sauce actually has the best overall taste from any sauce I've had. It is pretty hot overall, but the actual taste of it makes the hotness worth it. My favorite so far.
-313 Foodie Sauce, I saw this one when ordering the Hot Ones and decided to grab it. It is by far the hottest I've tried, but still has a solid taste.
Dave's:
Hurtin Jalapeno: B-
Cool Cayenne Pepper: C+
Insanity: F
Roasted Garlic (not pictured because it's in the trash): F--
Blair's:
Habanero Mango: B+
Chipotle Slam: B-
Wasabi Green Tea: F (close to being trashed with Dave's roasted garlic)
Jalapeno Tequila: C
Random:
Cholula Chili Lime: A
Dawson's Original Hot: A-
Trappey's Bull: B+
Sriracha: C
Frank's Original: B+
Hot Ones: A+
After taste testing all of these across multiple foods, these are the rankings I have personally made. They are judged based off taste, not hotness. Dave's Insanity sauce is good if you're in a dick measuring contest. The rest of these sauces are good for everyday use.
Hot Ones, no they're not paying me, is still the absolute best tasting hot sauce I've had across all of my tests. I may be slightly biased towards citrus hot sauces now that I look at my rankings. To each their own however.
Secret Aardvark: B+
Taste is good, spice is there, just a bit too "habanero-ey" tasting for me to put it on some meals I found. Used half the bottle in a week though, so it's definitely worth a purchase.
Pain 100%: A-
Not as hot as I thought it would be. Has a very similar taste to Frank's Red Hot with a lot more kick which is something I've wanted for a long time. If you're familiar with Domino's Kicker Hot Sauce or Frank's and want some more spice in your life, this is the one I'd recommend.
Bravado Pineapple and Habanero: Very sweet of course, with some kick. More mild than Hot Ones imo.
Scotch Bonnet: My least favorite sauce out of the bunch. Has a kick to it, but the taste of it just wasn't working for me.
Tiger Sauce: Bought a 5pk of this on accident on Amazon. I must say, it's pretty good on about anything. Not particularly hot, but has its place on many meals if you want to add a little kick.
Ghost Pepper & Blueberry: This is my new favorite sauce, taking over Hot Ones. I have cravings for this. The amount of sweetness from the Blueberries and the amount of hot from the ghost peppers is matched perfectly. Love this sauce.
Trader Joe's Habanero: Loved this one as well. It is now my favorite habanero sauce out of the mix.
I highly recommend the Bravado Ghost Pepper & Blueberry out of all the sauces I've tried. It is super tasty on wings. Warning: will turn everything it touches blue.
I just wanted to consolidate all my previous reviews into one post. Thank you for the recent replies, I will add them to my next order.