idk I think chump being regarded as #1 chase is pretty crazy honestly and I was around for the entirety of the scene.
dutch began as #1 chase, then probably snow (except he cheated) and me (although I don't get any recognition because I never played for either of the top 2 teams (who were always a mixture of the same 10 people). i don't know if i ever would've taken chump early
non was always known to be best lo bc he understood waht the position entailed, however, if you were to ask me who the most effective offensive player was, i'd say anemix.
as far as cappers go, lix was the most effective because in 5v5 a capper has never truly been solely responsible for route running... killing power has always had huge value as well, and he added in this category where many other cappers lacked (such as thorin)
home d... honestly, the most effective home d that I have ever consistently chased with was probably milk-man. dawar was pure chain and lacked a lot of flag skills.. stork has always been very good all around, tho I would've liked to see more home d guys get into TR...