I made this a separate post since it's kind of long, but Peter Laird--co-creator of TMNT--shared some thoughts on his blog. It's pretty long, but there are some good bits in there.
Peter Laird's Blogspot
and a little bit later...
Cliffs:
Peter Laird thinks it sucks while being sarcastic.
Peter Laird's Blogspot
Peter Laird said:But I would actually encourage TMNT fans to swallow the "chill pill" Mr. Bay recently suggested they take, and wait and see what might come out of this seemingly ill-conceived plan. It's possible that with enough truly creative brainpower applied to this idea, it might actually work. I'm not saying it's probable, or even somewhat likely… but it IS possible.
Peter Laird said:Over the years, I have made no secret of my distaste for what I consider to be the weak, facile, creatively bankrupt idea which can be summed up like this:
"If FOUR Ninja Turtles are good, then FIVE (or more) Ninja Turtles MUST be better!"
Peter Laird said:Anyway, to get back to the "TMNT are aliens" thing -- the reason I say it could be a "genius" idea is that -- for the first time -- someone has come up with a way to have as many freakin' Turtles as they want. I mean, if the TMNT are actually members of an alien race, there could be a whole PLANET of them!
and a little bit later...
Peter Laird said:Just so it's absolutely clear -- I think a planet of turtles is not, in and of itself, a bad idea for some kind of science fiction/fantasy story. But as a way to explain any aspect of the backstory of TMNT, I think it is awful and unnecessary.
Cliffs:
Peter Laird thinks it sucks while being sarcastic.