Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page
TribalWar Forums
Page 70 of 8751

TribalWar Forums (https://www.tribalwar.com/forums/index.php)
-   TWHOF (https://www.tribalwar.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=275)
-   -   [Mega] MAGA Super Trump Mega Thread (https://www.tribalwar.com/forums/showthread.php?t=686285)

phaytal 11-29-2016 13:25

OK, middle class, listen up. I'm going to subsidize these manufacturing jobs so that we can put some of these unskilled people back to work manufacturing bull**** that has been perfected overseas for years. But it's up to you, middle class, to pay 3x more for these goods and services or your fellow Americans won't have jobs!

:rofl:

Kerosene31 11-29-2016 13:26

I just don't see how we can compete with Chinese labor that will work for pennies on the dollar. They can make $1-2/hour while a US worker would need $10-20+.

Even if the US worker is 3 times as effective, they still aren't cost effective to overcome the 10x difference in wage.

I just don't see how you fix that without massively increasing the costs of goods here.

Rooster128 11-29-2016 13:30

Honestly Fool, I doubt you will find an answer using the same tools we've used before. Bringing work back home is important, but I don't see how we can do it. The problem lies in wealth disparity. It'd be nice if some of that wealth could be given to small business owners, but I don't think we can exactly force people sitting on vast sums of cash to just give out their wealth.

I'd argue things like designer brands- and objects of "status symbol value" actually hurt our economy quite a bit. Making something expensive without offering a likewise increase in value (as others have said, sometimes an item appearing superior in quality actually isn't) is essentially leeching millions of dollars of value. And all that wealth ends up in the pockets of makers of said "luxury item" - not the typical hard working joe at a small business.

IDK though... I could be wrong. IDK if that's actually a big player in this arena, but to me it appears that way. Rich people using money for dumb ****.

amRam 11-29-2016 13:42

DeWalt has tools now with 'assembled in USA' stickers on em.. they're priced in line with all the other ****. Not sure how much of the assembly is taking place stateside, but whatever. I wonder if the distribution/shipping costs are offset enough to get the pricing down.

phaytal 11-29-2016 13:46

Assembled is the key word. What does it take to put a Dewalt drill together once you know what you're doing? 5 minutes? 10 minutes? That isn't adding much overhead to your bottom line, because it's the smallest part of the manufacturing process.

Now what if the battery were made in the US? The brushless motor? The circuit boards? The steel and plastic housings? Now you've got a $500 drill.

spockhammer 11-29-2016 13:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by phaytal (Post 18681516)
OK, middle class, listen up. I'm going to subsidize these manufacturing jobs so that we can put some of these unskilled people back to work manufacturing bull**** that has been perfected overseas for years. But it's up to you, middle class, to pay 3x more for these goods and services or your fellow Americans won't have jobs!

:rofl:

trump logic

yes **** the global economy so i can put hotels in china

TOTALLY THE BEST STRATEGY

SuicideSnowman 11-29-2016 13:55

https://i.sli.mg/AK2czM.jpg

Send more money guys.

MadHatSam 11-29-2016 13:56

That big infrastructure bill he wants has a nice cushy guaranteed 10% pretax profit for contractors. Lets get that gravy train rolling!

SuicideSnowman 11-29-2016 14:00

Damn if you guys were this critical about all the stupid **** Obama did, there might not even be a president Trump.

Kerosene31 11-29-2016 14:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by phaytal (Post 18681531)
Assembled is the key word. What does it take to put a Dewalt drill together once you know what you're doing? 5 minutes? 10 minutes? That isn't adding much overhead to your bottom line, because it's the smallest part of the manufacturing process.

Now what if the battery were made in the US? The brushless motor? The circuit boards? The steel and plastic housings? Now you've got a $500 drill.

Right. It is probably cheaper to ship the parts separately anyway and mass produce them. You've got to do quality control with more skilled people anyway so why not just put them together here.

Assembly isn't exactly turning the rust belt into boomtown.

Fool 11-29-2016 14:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by phaytal (Post 18681516)
perfected overseas for years

Perfected? You mean throwing a cheap labor force at it? People have been doing that for centuries.

lemontw 11-29-2016 14:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by MadHatSam (Post 18681538)
That big infrastructure bill he wants has a nice cushy guaranteed 10% pretax profit for contractors. Lets get that gravy train rolling!

A 10% pre-tax profit is cushy?

Ixiterra 11-29-2016 14:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by lemontw (Post 18681547)
A 10% pre-tax profit is cushy?

typical profit margin on a larger construction job is 2-3%, but I don't know anything about what madhatsam is talking about

phaytal 11-29-2016 14:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fool (Post 18681546)
Perfected? You mean throwing a cheap labor force at it? People have been doing that for centuries.

You're the king and sidestepping actual points and nitpicking about bull****.

Congrats?

MadHatSam 11-29-2016 14:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by lemontw (Post 18681547)
A 10% pre-tax profit is cushy?

The guaranteed part, can't lose money on that contract.

Fool 11-29-2016 14:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by phaytal (Post 18681549)
You're the king and sidestepping actual points and nitpicking about bull****.

Congrats?

I agree with you honestly, I was just pointing out the absurdity of one of your claims. Unless Americans are willing to pay more, those specific manufacturing jobs aren't the answer. I'm simply saying we need to find a solution, because manufacturing is only the beginning of the end of the American workforce.

cael 11-29-2016 14:21

i say **** em

they voted 4 trump anyway so we don't have to care

MadHatSam 11-29-2016 14:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ixiterra (Post 18681548)
typical profit margin on a larger construction job is 2-3%, but I don't know anything about what madhatsam is talking about

It is from Trump's infrastructure plan, which is mostly a giant tax credit for private equity to fund these projects. One of the components of the plan is that contractors would receive 10% profits pretax, the income taxes on these profits are one of the main government revenue streams required to make the plan revenue neutral.

Odio 11-29-2016 14:23

on this page: Liberals struggle with basic economic concepts.

Esteban_Villa 11-29-2016 14:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by phaytal (Post 18681495)
Dude... The US makes up 4% of the global population. Is your US manufactured product, which costs 3x more than an identical Chinese product, going to sell anywhere else in the world simply because it was made in the good ol' US of A?

Come down to Earth, friend.

That's why I said other costs need to be made to push it back towards 50. The numbers I used are rough estimates and easy to mental math versions of the Apple FYI

Products like the iPhone (consumer retail good) wouldn't have much of value added because Westerners like to talk about child labor laws, but not care about where their coffee actually comes from. However, the decreasing of Corporate Tax rate will also serve to maintain the profit margin, as that is primary thing that needs to stay the same. IDK if you're American or not but it's like getting a new car, the only thing that matters is the MSRP and negotiating that lower. All the bells and whistles otherwise are there are a shell game. If a product costs 3x as much to make but laws are put into placed mandated the making of it in the USA and the profit margin stays the same, businesses will give 0 ****s. In the end, Trump doesn't give a **** about other countries and if you don't get an iPhone but he creates more actual American jobs that are middle class and Apple losses some market cap, who the **** cares? He's not here to serve the global people - he's here to serve the AMERICAN people. period.

I understand how the potential transitioning away from a free trade economy has people up in a tizzy as systems are in place to encourage it. With automation however, we are shifting back towards a protectionist one and the key thing in business is to be the first at it. Apple got it's start as being among the first of consumer retail operating systems, they understand. Free trade has started to become to crab bucket mentality and I don't fault the other crabs err countries for trying to cry and pull us back in. As the #1 economy in the world, we have the leverage to do that. Even the EU/China/Russia/UK/Japan do too, it's just the belief is there that you can not, you just have to have something unique that others will want to buy, that's how Russia stays very relevant given it's mineral extraction enterprises. German and Luxembourg stays relevant in steal manufacturing by making ultra precise and unique pieces, even though the Ruhr valley is a shell of it's former self for resource extraction. Find a niche, and exploit it. Or, have the system in place for that opportunity to grow.

There are other factors in play too like the cost of building the new factory, threat of China shutting down Foxconn early, etc.

Anyone who says moving production to the USA without other regulations/laws being put into place is wrong. Anyone who says it's impossible even with those laws/regulations is also wrong. Serious excise taxes designed to mold the economy used to be a primary income generator for all Western countries, and the fact it's back on the table has people in a huff as we've gone a century where it's only trended away. Shake ups always worry people, just like Obamacare. When something is ****ed, a situation needs to be shaken up or you will slowly be strangled to death. Not all shake ups are good, but there are merits here you are missing.


Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 21:24.
Page 70 of 8751

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2003, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All Content Copyright 1999-2020 Tribalwar.Com, LLC