I wonder if ****ing a real Jewish girl (an Israeli Jew or an orthodox Jew rather than a non-practicing American Jew) would feel weird. Not physically, obviously, but just sort of akward.
No matter how nice Jewish people are to non-Jews there is always just this feeling that they are keeping themselves apart from those who aren't pure. You get the same vibe from Mormons for example.
That must be how it feels to be a minority - no matter what people say or do you always feel a little bit excluded or isolated.