T2 was actualy well done in many ways, but many (not all) staunch T1 vets that never gave it a chance after the release debacle, never came back to realize how good it became with mods like classic and base ++, along with the new audience of players it attracted with its base gameplay and mods like vehicles, great tribal war etc. T2's rejection on release by many vets wasnt just due to the endless patches to fix bugs, but the fact that the gameplay speed (skiing, jetting etc) was seriously nerfed. Big factor even in light of the bugs.
TV is definitely not buggy like T2 was on its release, and yes it has a good single player game and the skiing is fast and easy. With that said however, I dont think the MP of TV is as feature rich and a good evolution for Tribes in terms of game design and features compared to T2. With T2 they nerfed the speed to hell in a great design version ofTribes. With TV they did the complete opposite. They figured the way to make the game popaular was to provide a full complete SP and simply make it fast. Thats good and all, but everything else was ripped out or diminshed. Yes the ski speed factor is in TV, but a lot of everything else leaves you feeling a bit empty and buggy.
Like T2, I'm hopeful that TV will improve and become a great game. (Im trying to move away from the hate club). My only concern is that bugs can be fixed, but its easier to adjust an attribute like speed (added to T2 easily) versus trying to build in and modify the engine to put back everything that was removed or watered down in TV.
And by the way Shieldpackman you make T2 players seem like dimwits to some of the vets you're harking on here. I dont think you realize some of these folks are legends of the Tribes world. You really need to quit with the hate trolling. There is a Tribes game we can all like, but putting everyone down doesnt help.