For all the fallout fanboys who like to hate on this game. If it came out and was based on mad max meets The Road and had a different name what would your opinion of it be?
That's the main point of contention.
No Mutants Allowed for all its hate (and boy can they hate) admits that if this was not a sequel to fallout, they would consider it a good enough game. There was a poll on NMA a ways back, and most people would bitch less if it was just considered a spinoff like Tactics. Most of them would put up with Oblivion gameplay if they hadn't fucked with the setting and plot as well (I know I would).
They're not pissed because it's not a good game, they're pissed because it's not Fallout and Bethesda basically just used the franchise as a massive publicity stunt to sell their new oblivion, ignoring what made the Fallout franchise such a big name in the process, and what's worse, they're essentially restarting the entire franchise with something that is inferior.
You can't just grab a franchise, throw away everything that made it a franchise in the first place and then expect the people who have been supporting it for decades to accept what you just did with open arms; especially if the whole time you're lying to them, insulting them and ultimately ignoring them.
Hell, most people on TW are PC gamers. When someone grabs a PC game and dumbs it down for consoles, it's fucking annoying.
That's what Fallout 3 is. They can claim it's a PC game first, but it's a dumbed down Fallout for the console generation.