Rating T1, T2, and TV from 1 to 10

Shoddy said:
Diverse crowd -> diverse opinions

T1: 8
T2 at launch: 5
T2 late: 9
TV: 7

Hard to reduce things to a number :/
Click to expand...

^^^ Totally agree, except TV is a 6 so far. Maybe with mods and some dev support it can one day be a 9. It's mostly a 6 because of the graphics, the lack of depth keeps it from going any higher..
 
T1: 10 as good a game as I've ever played
T2-base: 1 total letdown from T1 - slow & buggy
T2-classic: 6 playable
T:V 8 playable but not great
 
T1: 8
T2: 9.5 (Base++)
T2: 6 (Classic)
TV: 4

edit: woot, atleast someone else admitted to liking T2 base/++ better than classic.
 
Last edited:
Judging by these ratings, T1 should have a revival soon... Or do people prefer "new" over "fun"?

T1 - 10
T2 - 4
T:V - 5
 
T1 - 9
T2 - 10 (including base, classic and some other mods I've played)
T:V - 8

I love tribes :)
 
Slitz said:
Judging by these ratings, T1 should have a revival soon... Or do people prefer "new" over "fun"?

T1 - 10
T2 - 4
T:V - 5
Click to expand...
I think T1 is getting such high scores because at its time it was something brand new (refer to LogRoller's theory).


It could be remade as a T:V mod, but I don't think it would be much more alive than it is right now.


Oh, and update:

T:V retail: 7.5 (SP = teh win :bigthumb: )
 
T1 - 8 - I wish I had played it more
T2 - 10 - best $50 I have ever spent
T:V - 9 (so far)
T:V SP = 10 - doesn't get any better than this

I too love TRIBES
 
T1: 8
T2: 10 (mainly because Shrikes :heart:) When Classic came along I didnt shrike anymore, but the gameplay was awesome without it so its still 10 for both.
TV: 5

And I thought the T:V SP sucked :|
But I have high standards I guess. The overall story was interesting, how they told it, and the graphics/scenes/etc sucked imo.
 
Last edited:
t1: 9.0 (after most patches)
t2: 9.5 (after patches, before classic)
tv: 5.0 (as a general game. 2.5 as a TRIBES game)

T:V might sit well in the Starsiege universe, but it isn't really a TRIBES game.
 
Back
Top