As with most games, I'm not sure what the point is of attacking this project at this point. I know the internet is full of contrarians and it's really cool to hate on this because of schilling, if you're one of those counter culture nerdlings, but honestly the proof will be in the pudding.
They've very obviously assmbled some good talent, and lord knows he's a competitive guy who isn't going to put this much effort into something half assed.
And honestly, at the end of the day, it's going to be released, and a fuck load of people are going to love it, another fuck load are going to hate it, and there's really not ever going to be a way to be right or wrong, it'll be their spin on how an MMO should be, and for some people it will be a revelation, and for others it'll be a bastardization and they'll go back to leveling another character to the ceiling on WOW
I guess i just don't see the point of bitching based on a couple of screenshots. Someone new throws their hat into the ring and in a really big way, this seems like something we should generally be excited about.
Full Disclosure: I am the guy who started the dirty water thread, I might not be unbiased on this subject