Warriors: Tanking Weapon Enchants?

Lifestealing or 15 Str?

more hate vs more attack power/block damage reduction?

+15 Agil for better dodge, defense, and crit rate.

block is based on defense only...

go +15agi if you're only thinking about tanking. The armor + dodge beats out the small life from crusader/lifesteal

Crusader...

Dodging dont give rage.

15 agility

anyone who says different is wrong

+2 beast slaying....fartypants is a newb.

Crusader...

Dodging dont give rage.
yes but it's total damage mitigation which is better then raids

and you should usually have full rage in mc and bwl and shit anyways

block is based on defense only...

25 str = 1 block value.

+15 agility is pretty much the best tanking enchant, although i wouldn't bother getting it unless you're running out of things to spend your gold on (aka learning wipes).

yes but it's total damage mitigation which is better then raids

and you should usually have full rage in mc and bwl and shit anyways
Never gotten a long string of dodges/parries on your part have you? It can be just as bad as missing several Sunders in a row since you'll have no rage to do anything with.

i've been told 15agi

25 str = 1 block value.

+15 agility is pretty much the best tanking enchant, although i wouldn't bother getting it unless you're running out of things to spend your gold on (aka learning wipes).
Concur.

i use +15 agi

Just to clarify some numbers, +15 Agi adds 30 armor and 0.8% dodge. Not really worth the gold imo. I use crusader, when it procs it heals for 100 some, and increases block value by about 4. Whatever the enchant, it's not going to make a big difference.