500Watts said:
one is the original version. then the record company added the male vocal guy for newer version to hip things up.
What he said
If you can see past Paul McCoy's voice on BMTL, keeping in mind he isn't with the band, and enjoy the band as it really is, I highly recommend buying "Fallen", and downloading their older stuff. Some of it may not appeal to you (accoustic, slower) but some of the old stuff is really fucking good.
I'd link to my Evanescence playlist, but since my host is down...
1. Evanescence - Anything For You (3:25)
2. Evanescence - Anywhere (6:03)
3. Evanescence - Ascension of the Spirit (3:16)
4. Evanescence - Away From Me (3:30)
5. Evanescence - Before The Dawn (3:17)
6. Evanescence - Breathe No More (3:49)
7. Evanescence - Bring Me To Life (3:57)
8. Evanescence - Bring Me To Life (Acoustic) (3:53)
9. Evanescence - Bring Me To Life (Demo) (3:58)
10. Evanescence - Eternal (7:22)
11. Evanescence - Even In Death (4:09)
12. Evanescence - Even in Death (Acoustic) (3:36)
13. Evanescence - Everybody's Fool (3:15)
14. Evanescence - Exodus (3:05)
15. Evanescence - Farther Away (3:53)
16. Evanescence - Fields Of Innocence (5:13)
17. Evanescence - Forever Gone Forever You (3:24)
18. Evanescence - Forgive Me (3:01)
19. Evanescence - Give unto me (5:49)
20. Evanescence - Going Under (3:35)
21. Evanescence - Goodnite (1:32)
22. Evanescence - Haunted (3:06)
23. Evanescence - Hello (3:40)
24. Evanescence - Imaginary (4:17)
25. Evanescence - Imaginary (Demo) (3:18)
26. Evanescence - Imaginary (EP version) (4:01)
27. Evanescence - Imaginary (Mystery) (4:09)
28. Evanescence - Imaginary (Origin) (3:31)
29. Evanescence - Lies (3:49)
30. Evanescence - Listen To The Rain (3:13)
31. Evanescence - Missing (3:26)
32. Evanescence - Missing (Fallen) (4:15)
33. Evanescence - My Immortal (4:24)
34. Evanescence - My Immortal (Origin) (4:26)
35. Evanescence - My Last Breath (4:07)
36. Evanescence - October (6:26)
37. Evanescence - Orestes (Cover) (5:49)
38. Evanescence - So Close (4:29)
39. Evanescence - Solitude (5:46)
40. Evanescence - Surrender (3:37)
41. Evanescence - Taking Over Me (3:50)
42. Evanescence - Taking Over Me (Demo) (3:41)
43. Evanescence - The End (Outro) (1:59)
44. Evanescence - Tourniquet (4:38)
45. Evanescence - Understanding (Original) (7:21)
46. Evanescence - Understanding (Sound Asleep Version) (4:51)
47. Evanescence - Unknown (Must Be Dreaming) (4:18)
48. Evanescence - Where Will You Go (3:47)
49. Evanescence - Whisper (5:27)
50. Evanescence - Whisper (Origin) (4:31)